Consider, Federal, Municipal, Provincial

“I am a taxpayer and I’m entitled …

Leave a comment

The television news report on Royal Columbian Hospital using Tim Hortons for emergency patients had an on camera interview with a daughter who’s mother was one of the patients in Tim Hortons who stated “how awful that you’ve been a taxpayer all of your life … that your end days are with that kind of quality of care … there is no excuse for that, I think they should be ashamed.”

I have heard, I suspect we have all heard – perhaps have stated ourselves – variations on the ‘I’m a taxpayer! What am I paying taxes for? I have paid taxes all my life……….

I had just spoken to a class at UFV on affordable housing, homelessness, addiction, mental illness, poverty and related social issues stating that these were not problems but consequences of both the way politics is practiced and the way though is practiced. More accurately about what we ‘know’ or what is ‘known’ or ‘common knowledge’ and how if we applied thought to these matters we would find or realize reality is markedly different from what is ‘known’.

When I heard the ‘been a taxpayer all my life’ statement I found myself examining the implications, the entitlement, contained in that statement. While the statement has the appearance or semblance of truth, when one carefully examines, carefully considers the statement it becomes clear that all it has is the appearance of truth.

The underlying fiscal reality for those who have paid taxes all their life is that what they are entitled to is CPP. The chart of Canada’s national debt below shows clearly that only those who retired prior to 1944 can make claims upon the federal government beyond CPP.

Year                                       Federal Debt

Prior to WW II                  $0

1944                                    $ 8,000,000,000

1961-62                             $ 14,825,000,000

1970-71                            $ 20,293,000,000

1980-81                              $ 91,948,000,000

1990-91                             $377,656,000,000

1996-97                            $562,881,000,000

2001-02                           $511,946,000,000

2007-08                          $457,637,000,000

2008-09                          $463,710,000,000

2009-10                          $519,100, 000,000

2010-11                           $522,337, 000,000 (projected)

2011-12                           $535,237, 000,000 (projected)

2012-13                          $542,537, 000,000 (projected)

If you purchase something for $1,500 and you pay out $1500 it is yours as you have paid out the full price of your purchase and are entitled to benefit from your purchase.

If you buy the something for $1500 and only pay $1200 you still owe $300 that must be paid and until you pay the final $300 you are not entitled to your purchase.

Beginning in 1944 Canadian taxpayers have been paying only a portion of the price of their ‘purchases’ of federal government services, borrowing to cover the remaining cost of the federal services ‘purchased’, putting the balance on a federal credit card- a balance that remains to be paid, a balance that continues to grow.

So, while taxpayers have paid taxes all their lives they have failed to pay sufficient taxes to cover the cost of the federal government . Taxpayers have avoided paying the full tab by running deficits, adding the outstanding unpaid yearly balances to the federal debt.

Every Canadian man, woman or child has/owes their portion of the federal debt, the debt of the province they reside in and the debt of the municipality they live in.

So while Canadians may be entitled to the CPP they paid into, the only ones entitled to anything else from the federal, provincial or municipal governments are those who loaned money to these governmental bodies and are entitled to repayment of principal plus interest.

Receiving medical care in Tim Hortons is a consequence of the decisions taxpayers have made (spending on the Winter Olympic venues rather than hospitals), together with years of choosing not to pay the full cost of all the services they were receiving from government.

If Canadians don’t want to be receiving medical care in Tim Hortons or hospital hallways they need to make better choices, to be willing to make hard decisions, face fiscal realities, understand we cannot have everything we want ‘right now’ and be willing to pay the full cost of the services etc we want (receive) from federal, provincial and municipal governments.

If Canadians don’t change our behaviours, choices and decision making, the days when you got medical services in the Tim Hortons at Royal Columbian are going to be the ‘good old days’ of public health care.

Issues

NOT a homeless woman’s shelter.

Leave a comment

People were telling me about reading of a new homeless woman’s shelter that was going to open in Abbotsford.

Since I was unaware of plans for a homeless woman’s shelter/housing, I searched out a paper to read the article people were referring to. And there was the headline: ” New housing project for homeless women.”

Compounding the headline’s ability to create the wrong impression, the article did not clearly set out the purpose of the housing project on Clearbrook Road was and why the project was important for the wellness of the project’s residents and in addressing homelessness in Abbotsford.

This is not a shelter it is an apartment building. Homeless, mentally ill, addicted women will not be snatched off the street to live in the project. As Ms Willis stated: “This is an alcohol- and drug-free facility, and there will be no high-risk clients.”

It is second stage housing for Abbotsford, similar to the 13 units of second-stage housing the Women’s Resource Society of the Fraser Valley operates in Mission at Taulbut House. It will provide affordable housing so the women do not become homeless or have to live in danger of becoming homeless.

I can attest to how attention diverting, stressful and wearing it is when you are never sure you will have a place to live next month – until the moment when you have managed to pay the rent at the beginning of the next month. At which point the cycle of worrying whether you will have housing the following month begins to gnaw at you mind again.

The security, the stability, that affordable housing provides is invaluable in being able to focus on getting your life back on track, is a vital support to the woman (and their children) in getting their lives back on track.

” Executive director Pamela Willis said the Clearbrook Road project will allow the society to offer a a new level of support to women. “

Support is, in its way, even more important than affordable housing in getting your life back on track, in getting through the rough spots and over barriers.

I say this because it was support from friends that allowed me to overcome problems and not end up homelss in 2010. Friends were also the reason I made it through 2010 and the challenge posed by the rationing of mental health services.

Recovery and finding wellness is not a short, simple or easy process. Which is why the housing and support provided by the Clearbrook Road project is so needed.

There are emergency shelter spaces for woman who are homeless. There are first stage/minimal barrier spaces – although not nearly enough. There are treatment and recovery house spaces for woman.

What there hasn’t been – and what this project will provide – is safe, healthy, supportive, affordable housing to allow women to continue their journey of recovery, to help them get their lives back on track and to help them (and their children) find wellness and joy.

Caveat emptor, Federal, Issues, Municipal, Provincial

Society is Our choices.

Leave a comment

A recent e-mail sent me to the Chilliwack Today website to read a column inspired by a Chilliwack Progress story concerning the proposed establishment of the Chilliwack Contact Center * for helping those living on the streets by converting the Days Inn hotel currently operating on Young Road.

*[A facility designed to offer housing and health services and solutions to the homeless that, according to Chilliwack MLA John Les will make a difference in people’s lives and improve our community. Medical care, court advocacy, rental assistance as well as help for those facing mental health or addictions issues.]

The first thought was about how many projects like this and other affordable housing projects have been bypassing, or in the case of the Olympic legacy housing passing right through, Abbotsford on the way to Chilliwack.

While Abbotsford ‘s Mayor and council have been very good at saying the right things and paying lip service to the need for affordable housing, they have failed at providing action based leadership on this issue, as they have on so many other pressing city issues (secure water supply, facilities and road maintenance, etc). Seeming to bury their heads in the sand, as if these issues/problems will disappear on their own.

But I digress.

The column and story were about a major, perhaps the major, problem that has given birth to our current society and that prevents us from addressing the problems and issues Canada and Canadians face – IT IS ALL ABOUT ME!

Which reared its ugly head in opposition to the Chilliwack Contact Centre.

You can recognize the presence of IT IS ALL ABOUT ME syndrome by the use of buzzwords or buzz-statements such as those uttered by area resident Renée Woods: “It’s not that I’m against the project in any way, I think Chilliwack definitely needs it.”

‘Woods main concern is the location, asking why the health contact centre couldn’t be established downtown instead.’

I cannot say whether those suffering from IT IS ALL ABOUT ME are lying to themselves or to the public to excuse their actions and obscure the reality that they are opposing the project they claim not to be against.

A location has been chosen, plans specific to that location have been prepared, a deal to purchase the property has been agreed upon – all that remains is rezoning. If the rezoning is not approved the Centre does not come into existence.

Regardless of how you try to spin it or delude oneself, the reality is that if you oppose the rezoning you oppose the Chilliwack Centre.

A reality more clearly seen in Ms Woods words “I’m worried that they’re just moving the problem from downtown to here. I feel they are taking the lowest socioeconomic group and moving it a block from my house,” she said. “If it changes the dynamic of our neighbourhood, it’s unfair.”

I believe I will let her words speak for, or more accurately against, themselves.

The deep, dark humour/irony here is the existence of neighbourhoods were Ms. Wood is seen as a member of the lower socioeconomic classes whose mere presence would change the dynamic of the neighbourhood.

People speak as though society results for someone else’s actions, is someone else’s fault as though their behaviours have nothing to do with or no effect on society.

Our society has been built and continues to be built by the choices, actions and behaviours of all of us. Every choice we make, every action we take – or don’t take, how we behave creates the society we live in.

In September 2010 I wrote about a business man who, finding a homeless man and his dog camped out under the awning of his building did not have man and dog removed but purchased a garden shed and installed it at the side of the building to provide shelter from the elements for man and dog.

This week the homeless man came down with pneumonia, requiring hospitalization. Once again the businessman stepped up to the plate when nothing compelled him to do so, except his own code of behaviour, and took the homeless dog home with him to make sure he is cared for.

The Society so many deplore is created and shaped by us. Society is us, our choices, actions and behaviours.

Choose which society you want to bring into being – the one that is created by Ms. Woods words, actions and attitudes OR the one that is created by the actions, attitudes and behaviour of the businessman.

Your/Our choices bring into being the Society we choose. If you do not like the Society that we live in – change your behaviour and influence others to change their behaviours until the Society you/we want exists.